January 2012 Archives by date
Starting: Mon Jan 2 10:46:31 PST 2012
Ending: Tue Jan 31 21:02:47 PST 2012
Messages: 137
- [EM] MMTA's conditionality doesn't work. Immodest statements about methods' & system's merits.
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Forest: MAMD
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] MAMD (Max Assent Min Dissent)
fsimmons at pcc.edu
- [EM] MAMD (Max Assent Min Dissent)
fsimmons at pcc.edu
- [EM] Re et al Chicken and Egg
David L Wetzell
- [EM] MAMD (Max Assent Min Dissent)
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Chris: ABF grading
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Does Bucklin 2-level satisfy Participation (mono-add-top)?
Ted Stern
- [EM] Does Bucklin 2-level satisfy Participation (mono-add-top)?
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Three Slot Voting Equipment
fsimmons at pcc.edu
- [EM] Does Bucklin 2-level satisfy Participation (mono-add-top)?
Kristofer Munsterhjelm
- [EM] Kristofer: MMPO objections
Kristofer Munsterhjelm
- [EM] Kristofer: MMPO objections
Kristofer Munsterhjelm
- [EM] Does Bucklin 2-level satisfy Participation (mono-add-top)?
Ted Stern
- [EM] Kristofer: MMPO objections
fsimmons at pcc.edu
- [EM] Kristofer: Mono-Add-Plump
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Perspective on FBC/ABE methods, conditional methods in particular.
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] I now propose a mock 2012 presidential election, by parties instead of candidates.
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] I now propose a mock 2012 presidential election, by parties instead of candidates.
Ted Stern
- [EM] I now propose a mock 2012 presidential election, by parties instead of candidates.
David L Wetzell
- [EM] A Bucklin-based Droop proportional method with few monotonicity problems
Kristofer Munsterhjelm
- [EM] Voting reform pitch
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Poll conditionality options. Conditionality approaches. Sequential nested conditionality.
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Ted: Regarding Poll
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] David: Regarding Poll
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] SODA description adjustment
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] A problem with IRV3/AV3
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Nested Sequential Conditionality didn't seem useful. CL Disqualification MMPO (CLDMMPO)
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Small fix for MTAOC conditinality
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] I retract the posting about changing MTAOC conditionality. Answering a criticicism.
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] A problem with IRV3/AV3 (Jameson Quinn)
David L Wetzell
- [EM] CLDMM{O
fsimmons at pcc.edu
- [EM] A problem with IRV3/AV3 (Jameson Quinn)
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] SODA: polls via "like/+1/reddit"; resulting nonmonotonicity; natural fix
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] AERLO in conditional voting. Speculations.
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] CLDMMPO
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] CLDMMPO
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] non-monotonicity in SODA
David L Wetzell
- [EM] non-monotonicity in SODA
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] non-monotonicity in SODA
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] CLDMMPO
fsimmons at pcc.edu
- [EM] CLDMMPO
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] MMPO with sum of disapprovals as an oppposition
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Oops! MMPO with summed disapprovals as an opposition elects B in ABE. FBC/ABE roundup.
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Oops! MMPO with summed disapprovals as an opposition elects B in ABE. FBC/ABE roundup.
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] I should have listed SODA. The conditional methods win, _among the ballots-only methods_.
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Clarifying Enhanced DMC (AKA SPARR Voting)
Ted Stern
- [EM] A few poll comments
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] suggested improvement on Mutual Majority criterion/set (and MTA reviewd)
C.Benham
- [EM] TTPBA//TR (a 3-slot ABE solution)
C.Benham
- [EM] MTA
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Kristofer: MMPO objections
C.Benham
- [EM] TTPBA,TR
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] TTPBA,TR
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] TTPBA,TR
C.Benham
- [EM] Poll Update
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Ballot
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] The list of ballotings didn't post well. So I'm re-posting it here
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] The list of ballotings didn't post well. So I'm re-posting it here
Ted Stern
- [EM] My ballot didn't post correctly. Re-posting it.
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] 3-Slot ratings
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] TTPBA//TR is innocent. Electing A is controversial.
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] TTPBA//TR is innocent. Electing A is controversial.
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Brief comment about IRV discussion
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Brief comment about IRV discussion
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Brief Comment on IRV debate
David L Wetzell
- [EM] Brief Comment on IRV debate
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Brief Comment on IRV debate
robert bristow-johnson
- [EM] Brief Comment on IRV debate
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Dave, Jameson: IRV
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Dave, Jameson: IRV
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Brief Comment on IRV debate
David L Wetzell
- [EM] IRV debate to RBJ and Mike O
David L Wetzell
- [EM] Brief Comment on IRV debate
robert bristow-johnson
- [EM] RBJ's Brief Comment on IRV debate
David L Wetzell
- [EM] Jameson reply
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Fwd: [Offline] IRV debate to RBJ and Mike O
David L Wetzell
- [EM] Fwd: [Offline] IRV debate to RBJ and Mike O
robert bristow-johnson
- [EM] My message posted without linebreaks. Disregard. Will fix it.
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] SODA
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] SODA
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] SODA posting with run-on lines (hopefully) fixed.
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] SODA posting with run-on lines (hopefully) fixed.
Dave Ketchum
- [EM] Dave reply, IRV
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Dave reply, IRV
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Sortition and the Delegable Proxy system
Bryan Mills
- [EM] Supernumerary. Subnumerarity.
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Sortition and the Delegable Proxy system
Raph Frank
- [EM] Sortition and the Delegable Proxy system
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Mike O.
David L Wetzell
- [EM] another re to Mike O.
David L Wetzell
- [EM] Mike O.
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Mike O.
David L Wetzell
- [EM] One more certainty wrt electoral reform.
David L Wetzell
- [EM] suggested improvement on Mutual Majority criterion/set (add-plump proofed MM)
C.Benham
- [EM] Two more 3-slot FBC/ABE solutions
C.Benham
- [EM] Two more 3-slot FBC/ABE solutions
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Two more 3-slot FBC/ABE solutions
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Published references for CW/ Range winner relation?
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Two more 3-slot FBC/ABE solutions (not)
Chris Benham
- [EM] Published references for CW/ Range winner relation?
robert bristow-johnson
- [EM] Strategy in two kinds of FBC/ABE methods
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Published references for CW/ Range winner relation?
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Re et al Chicken and Egg
Kristofer Munsterhjelm
- [EM] Sortition and the Delegable Proxy system
Kristofer Munsterhjelm
- [EM] Published references for CW/ Range winner relation?
Kristofer Munsterhjelm
- [EM] Re et al Chicken and Egg
Fred Gohlke
- [EM] Re et al Chicken and Egg
Kristofer Munsterhjelm
- [EM] General strategy and proposabiliy
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Propose plain Approval first. Option enhancements can be later proposals.
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Re et al Chicken and Egg
David L Wetzell
- [EM] MO
David L Wetzell
- [EM] I should have listed SODA. The conditional methods win, _among the ballots-only methods_.
Kristofer Munsterhjelm
- [EM] Propose plain Approval first. Option enhancements can be later proposals.
Kristofer Munsterhjelm
- [EM] Propose plain Approval first. Option enhancements can be later proposals.
Juho Laatu
- [EM] Which matters more: Getting/Figuring Out the Best Single-Winner Rule or Incorporating More Multi-Winner Rules ASAP in the US?
David L Wetzell
- [EM] Majority Judgement
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] AERLO probably spoils FBC compliance.
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Re : Majority Judgement
Kevin Venzke
- [EM] Majority Judgement
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Kevin: Majority Judgement
MIKE OSSIPOFF
- [EM] Contextuality determines relative import of criterion.
David L Wetzell
- [EM] Kevin: Majority Judgement
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] Gaming the Vote
Ted Stern
- [EM] Gaming the Vote
robert bristow-johnson
- [EM] Sortition and the Delegable Proxy system
Bryan Mills
- [EM] Sortition and the Delegable Proxy system
Clinton Mead
- [EM] Majority Judgement
Kristofer Munsterhjelm
- [EM] Gaming the Vote
Kristofer Munsterhjelm
- [EM] Sortition and the Delegable Proxy system
Kristofer Munsterhjelm
- [EM] Sortition and the Delegable Proxy system
Clinton Mead
- [EM] Sortition and the Delegable Proxy system
Bryan Mills
- [EM] SODA is monotonic. Earlier failure/fix was actually for participation, not monotononicity.
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] STV+AV.
David L Wetzell
- [EM] STV+AV.
robert bristow-johnson
- [EM] SODA criteria
Jameson Quinn
- [EM] STV+AV.
Bryan Mills
Last message date:
Tue Jan 31 21:02:47 PST 2012
Archived on: Sun Jun 29 22:35:34 PDT 2014
This archive was generated by
Pipermail 0.09 (Mailman edition).