Democratizing the Senate

[DEMOREP1 at aol.com]

Alex wrote-

Draw a distinction between the people of the United States and the

institution of the State of California.  Forfeit some amount of democracy

by letting each state legislature pick a single Senator, and in exchange

receive an arguably larger amount of democracy in return:  A Senate in

which half of the members are chosen by PR.
----
D- NO THANKS.  The series of rotten-to-the-core compromises from 1787 hang on 
and on.  It took a horrific Civil War and 620,000 dead to get rid of some of 
such compromises --- slavery  (13th Amdt),  the 3/5 person clause for Rep 
seats (14th Amdt, Sec. 2) and the definition of elector (15th Amdt - negative 
in form).

It is ABSOLUTELY INTOLERABLE (and ultra-dangerous) that the U.S.A. government 
LAWS/ TREATIES over the PEOPLE of the U.S.A. are being made by an indirect 
minority rule regime (controlled by gangs of special interests) -- the 
floating gerrymanders for U.S.A. Reps, the semi-fixed gerrymander of the 
U.S.A. Senate and their combined effects in the Electoral College gerrymander 
for President/VP.

As to the Senate -- how about abolishing it just like slavery was abolished 
(and sent to the political history junkyard) ???

Alternative- Abolish it and then revive it -- perhaps having 100/101 Senators 
elected using proxy p.r. for 2 year terms in odd numbered years from circa 20 
districts -- 1 or more States or part of 1 State (such as CA) -- ONLY due to 
the passion/ panic problem which sometimes affects single house legislative 
bodies --- taking note that Nebraska (and various foreign regimes) have 
survived with single house legislative bodies.

The Vice-President (a vestige of the old king appointed Lt. Governors in the 
pre-1776 colonies) can be made a Department Head to have him/her doing 
something useful (while watching the health of the President).

It is only a matter of time before the more populous States cause a crisis 
about the indirect minority rule U.S.A. Senate.

----
For more information about this list (subscribe, unsubscribe, FAQ, etc), 
please see http://www.eskimo.com/~robla/em