[EM] unequal cumulative vote allocation

Bart Ingles bartman at netgate.net
Fri Sep 17 11:07:14 PDT 1999


Although it is generally good strategy to allocate points equally among
all choices under cumulative voting, there seem to be exceptions.

For example, in an election to fill several seats with a number of
different factions, you have two similar factions of equal size, who are
just barely "entitled" to three seats between them.  Ideally, they
should be able to run one candidate each, plus one "shared" candidate
that the two groups agree on.

With paper ballots, and each voter allowed 3 points to allocate, a voter
could give 2 points to his/her "own" candidate, and one point to the
"shared" candidate.

With the Peoria system, where a vote is always allocated equally among a
voter's choices, you can resort to massive coordination, or simply
instruct the voters to use a die from a Parcheesi game.  If the voter
rolls a 1 or 2, he should vote only for the party's favorite.  If the
voter rolls 3 or higher, vote for both the party favorite and the shared
candidate.



More information about the Election-Methods mailing list