[EM] Poll ballots
Richard, the VoteFair guy
electionmethods at votefair.org
Thu May 16 09:58:18 PDT 2024
Great work Kristofer, however ...
Not all the ballots have the same number of methods.
One of them with 24 methods omits the RCIPE method. I don't know which
method is missing from the other ballot with 24 methods.
Some ballots have more than 25 methods, which I presume are write-in
methods. How are these write-in methods ranked on other ballots?
Thank you Kristofer!!
Richard Fobes
The VoteFair guy
On 5/16/2024 9:26 AM, Kristofer Munsterhjelm wrote:
> Here's my transcription of the poll ballots. Let me know if I got any of
> them wrong, so I can fix them. Approval cutoffs are marked with dashes,
> and double dashes/equal signs separate the different ballots. Omitted
> numbers indicate equal-rank:
>
> =============================================================
>
> Michael Ossipoff:
>
> 1 Approval
> 2 STAR
> 3 Approval with manual runoff
> 4 Benham
> Schwartz Woodall
> Woodall
> 7 Ranked Pairs (wv)
> 8 Minmax (wv)
> 9 Smith//Approval (implicit)
> --------------------------
> 10 Schulze
> 11 Baldwin
> Condorcet//Borda (Black)
> Copeland//Borda (Ranked Robin)
> Double Defeat, Hare
> Margins-Sorted Approval
> Margins-Sorted Minimum Losing Votes
> Max Strength Transitive Beatpath
> Raynaud
> RCIPE
> Smith//Approval (explicit)
> Smith//DAC
> Smith//Score
> 23 Majority Judgement
> 24 IRV
> 25 Plurality
>
> =============================================================
>
> Michael Garman
>
> 1 IRV
> 2 STAR
> 3 Approval with manual runoff
> --------------------------
> 4 Approval
> 5 Baldwin
> Benham
> Condorcet//Borda (Black)
> Copeland//Borda (Ranked Robin)
> Double Defeat, Hare
> Minmax (wv)
> Majority Judgement
> Margins-Sorted Approval
> Margins-Sorted Minimum Losing Votes
> Max Strength Transitive Beatpath
> Ranked Pairs (wv)
> Raynaud
> RCIPE
> Schulze
> Schwartz Woodall
> Smith//Approval (explicit)
> Smith//Approval (implicit)
> Smith//DAC
> Smith//Score
> Woodall
> 25 Plurality
>
> =============================================================
>
> Chris Benham
>
> 1 Margins-Sorted Approval
> --------------------------
> 2 Smith//Approval (explicit)
> Smith//Approval (implicit)
> IRV
> Benham
> Double Defeat, Hare
> 7 Ranked Pairs (wv)
> Schulze
> 9 Approval
> 10 Minmax (wv)
> 11 Baldwin
> Condorcet//Borda (Black)
> Copeland//Borda (Ranked Robin)
> Margins-Sorted Minimum Losing Votes
> Max Strength Transitive Beatpath
> Raynaud
> RCIPE
> Schwartz Woodall
> Smith//DAC
> Smith//Score
> Woodall
> 22 Majority Judgement
> 23 STAR
> Approval with manual runoff
> Plurality
>
> =============================================================
>
> Joshua Boehme
>
> 1 Approval
> 2 Ranked Pairs (wv)
> 3 STAR
> 4 Woodall
> 5 Smith//DAC
> --------------------------
> 6 Minmax (wv)
> 7 RCIPE
> 8 Benham
> 9 Margins-Sorted Approval
> 10 Smith//Approval (explicit)
> 11 Approval with manual runoff
> 12 Margins-Sorted Minimum Losing Votes
> 13 Smith//Approval (implicit)
> 14 Double Defeat, Hare
> 15 Raynaud
> 16 Schulze
> 17 Schwartz Woodall
> 18 Smith//Score
> 19 Majority Judgement
> 20 Plurality
> 21 IRV
> 22 Condorcet//Borda (Black)
> 23 Baldwin
> 24 Copeland//Borda (Ranked Robin)
>
> =============================================================
>
> fdpk69p6uq
>
> 1 STAR
> 2 Smith//Score
> 3 Baldwin
> Benham
> Condorcet//Borda (Black)
> Copeland//Borda (Ranked Robin)
> Raynaud
> Minmax (wv)
> Ranked Pairs (wv)
> Schulze
> Schwartz Woodall
> Smith//Approval (explicit)
> Smith//Approval (implicit)
> Smith//DAC
> Woodall
> Margins-Sorted Approval
> Margins-Sorted Minimum Losing Votes
> Max Strength Transitive Beatpath
> 19 Approval with manual runoff
> 20 Approval
> --------------------------
> 21 RCIPE
> 22 Double Defeat, Hare
> 23 Majority Judgement
> 24 IRV
> 25 Plurality
>
> =============================================================
>
> Kristofer Munsterhjelm
>
> 1 Ranked Pairs (wv)
> 2 Schulze
> Benham
> 4 Woodall
> 5 Minmax (wv)
> --------------------------
> 6 Schwartz Woodall
> 7 Smith//Approval (implicit)
> Smith//Approval (explicit)
> 9 Smith//Score
> 10 Raynaud
> 11 Baldwin
> 12 Majority Judgement
> 13 Double Defeat, Hare
> Max Strength Transitive Beatpath
> Margins-Sorted Minimum Losing Votes
> Margins-Sorted Approval
> 17 Copeland//Borda (Ranked Robin)
> 18 Smith//DAC
> 19 Approval with manual runoff
> 20 STAR
> 21 RCIPE
> 22 Condorcet//Borda (Black)
> 23 Approval
> 24 IRV
> 25 Plurality
>
> =============================================================
>
> Robert Bristow-Johnson
>
> 1 Condorcet//Plurality
> 2 Minmax (wv)
> 3 Ranked Pairs (wv)
> 4 Schulze
> 5 BTR-IRV
> --------------------------
> 6 Baldwin
> Benham
> Condorcet//Borda (Black)
> Copeland//Borda (Ranked Robin)
> Margins-Sorted Approval
> Margins-Sorted Minimum Losing Votes
> Max Strength Transitive Beatpath
> Raynaud
> Schwartz Woodall
> Smith//Approval (explicit)
> Smith//Approval (implicit)
> Smith//DAC
> Smith//Score
> Woodall
> 20 IRV
> 21 Approval
> 22 STAR
> 23 Plurality
> 24 Score
>
> =============================================================
>
> Richard Fobes
>
> 1 RCIPE
> 2 Benham
> 3 Minmax (wv)
> 4 Ranked Pairs (wv)
> 5 Woodall
> --------------------------
> 6 Schwartz Woodall
> 7 Baldwin
> 8 Copeland//Borda (Ranked Robin)
> 9 Condorcet//Borda (Black)
> 10 Schulze
> 11 Smith//Score
> 12 Raynaud
> 13 Max Strength Transitive Beatpath
> 14 Margins-Sorted Minimum Losing Votes
> 15 Smith//DAC
> 16 Double Defeat, Hare
> 17 IRV
> 18 Majority Judgement
> 19 STAR
> 20 Approval
> 21 Margins-Sorted Approval
> 22 Smith//Approval (explicit)
> 23 Smith//Approval (implicit)
> 24 Plurality
> 25 Approval with manual runoff
>
> =============================================================
>
> Toby Pereira
>
> 1 Approval
> 2 Smith//Score
> 3 Margins-Sorted Approval
> 4 Smith//Approval (explicit)
> 5 Ranked Pairs (wv)
> 6 Benham
> 7 Minmax (wv)
> 8 STAR
> --------------------------
> 9 Approval with manual runoff
> Baldwin
> Condorcet//Borda (Black)
> Copeland//Borda (Ranked Robin)
> Double Defeat, Hare
> IRV
> Majority Judgement
> Margins-Sorted Minimum Losing Votes
> Max Strength Transitive Beatpath
> Raynaud
> RCIPE
> Schulze
> Schwartz Woodall
> Smith//Approval (implicit)
> Smith//DAC
> Woodall
> 25 Plurality
>
> =============================================================
>
> Closed Limelike Curves
>
> 1 STAR
> 2 Smith//Score
> 3 Score
> 4 Majority Judgement
> 5 Approval
> Smith//Approval (explicit)
> Smith//Approval (implicit)
> Margins-Sorted Approval
> Double Defeat, Hare
> 10 Approval with manual runoff
> --------------------------
> 11 Ranked Pairs (wv)
> 12 Schulze
> 13 Baldwin
> Benham
> Copeland//Borda (Ranked Robin)
> Margins-Sorted Minimum Losing Votes
> Max Strength Transitive Beatpath
> Raynaud
> Schwartz Woodall
> Smith//DAC
> Woodall
> 22 Condorcet//Borda (Black)
> Minmax (wv)
> 24 RCIPE
> 25 IRV
> 26 Plurality
>
> =============================================================
>
> Filip Ejlak
>
> 1 Benham
> 2 Schwartz Woodall
> 3 Woodall
> 4 Ranked Pairs (wv)
> 5 Schulze
> 6 Max Strength Transitive Beatpath
> 7 Minmax (wv)
> 8 Raynaud
> 9 Baldwin
> 10 RCIPE
> 11 IRV
> --------------------------
> 12 Smith//DAC
> 13 Margins-Sorted Minimum Losing Votes
> 14 Margins-Sorted Approval
> 15 Smith//Approval (explicit)
> 16 Smith//Approval (implicit)
> 17 Smith//Score
> 18 Double Defeat, Hare
> 19 Copeland//Borda (Ranked Robin)
> 20 Condorcet//Borda (Black)
> 21 Approval
> 22 Majority Judgement
> 23 Score
> 24 Approval with manual runoff
> 25 STAR
> 26 Plurality
> 27 Borda
>
> -km
> ----
> Election-Methods mailing list - see https://electorama.com/em for list info
More information about the Election-Methods
mailing list