[EM] Election-Methods Digest, Vol 103, Issue 1

Fred Gohlke fredgohlke at verizon.net
Wed Jan 2 06:55:41 PST 2013


Good Morning, Jameson

re:  "Each voter grades each candidate from A to F. Voters may
       give as many or as few of each grade as they want. Then
       each candidate's grades are put in order and the similar
       grades are evenly spread out. For instance, grades of B
       (3.0) are evenly spread over a continuum between B+ (3.5)
       and B- (2.5)."

It is not clear how or why grades should be adjusted.  If a voter gives 
a candidate a grade of B, what is the justification for changing it to 
B+ or B-?  More to the point, what is the benefit?  If a candidate gets:

Grade   Voters
   A     26,781
   B    173,904
   C    155,781
   D    121,121
   E     81,286
   F     19,663

can not the candidate's grade be calculated without adjusting the value 
of any of the voters' wishes?

Fred



More information about the Election-Methods mailing list