[EM] [Election-Methods] [english 94%] PRfavoringracialminorities

Kristofer Munsterhjelm km-elmet at broadpark.no
Fri Aug 22 05:56:50 PDT 2008


Juho wrote:

> I could accept also methods where the voting power of each 
> representative is different. The good part is that such a parliament 
> would reflect the wishes of the voters more accurately than a parliament 
> where all the representatives have the same voting power. Maybe one 
> could force the voting power of different candidates within some agreed 
> range. That could be done by cutting only the power of the strongest 
> representatives and forwarding their excess votes to the nearest group 
> (or as indicated by the STV ballots).

Having different amounts of voting power would simplify multiwinner 
election systems considerably. One could, for instance, just do a FPTP 
count and then elect the n highest scoring, giving them voting power 
equal to the share of the total vote they got.

Still, that doesn't happen, and no assembly is set up that way. Why? 
Does it seem too unfair?



More information about the Election-Methods mailing list