[EM] it's pleocracy, not democracy
Abd ul-Rahman Lomax
abd at lomaxdesign.com
Sun Mar 4 21:02:18 PST 2007
At 03:29 PM 3/4/2007, Juho wrote:
>Single winner at its
>purest is just electing one of a number of candidates, giving no
>consideration to if it was the same voters that last time got their
>way through. Basic single winner methods maybe have worse utility
>than ones that take distribute the power over a sequence of
>decisions, but I'd still allow use of word "democratic" to describe
>them. Sometimes it makes sense to just forget the history.
If the goal is making the best decisions, altering the method so that
some specific group "gets its way" would seem less than ideal. It's noise.
There can be some value in noise in control systems. A noisy system
may be able to find states that would escape one that was running on
a fixed and accurate program.
However, that is probably unusual as a benefit. What *is* important
is that in public choice systems there be *some* flexibility.
How, indeed, it occurs to me to ask, are we to know who "got their
way" in a secret ballot system? The presumption might be that the
"way" was gotten by a party.
It would be just my luck that by the time I wised up and became a
Republican, the Democrats would get their turn. (Make no assumptions
about my personal politics from this.)
The system actually works better than it would work otherwise because
people shift allegiances. Somehow in this discussion it seems to have
been presumed that "the majority" is some fixed group of people, such
that it is unfair to "the minority" for the majority to always win.
Readers may know that I favor Range Voting as an election method,
which does not automatically choose the preference of the majority,
for it considers preference strength, if the voters choose to express
it. I've said it before and I'll probably say it again:
The majority properly has the right of decision, but it wisely
exercises this carefully, with consideration of possible harm done to
And everyone is a minority of some kind or at some time.
More information about the Election-Methods