[EM] Luxury strategy option for Condorcet
Michael Ossipoff
mikeo2106 at msn.com
Thu Jan 18 06:55:52 PST 2007
The Condorcet version that I propose is SSD, Schwartz Sequential Dropping.
It's defined at:
http://www.barnsdle.demon.co.uk/vote/sing.html
The strategy option that I describe here, and all strategy enhancements, are
not something that I suggest to include in an initial SSD proposal. But they
could be useful later, if people becomse concerned about strategy.
The Automatic Rank Line Option (ARLO) is a combination of ATLO (in reverse)
and AERLO. It's better than either, and I hereby replace them with it.
If a voter marks an ARLO line between 2 rank positions in his/her ranking,
that means that s/he wants to do the following:
All the above-line candidates are ranked in the order listed. All the
below-line candidates are truncatred (power-truncated if power truncation is
allowed--and it should be allowed).
There are up to 3 counts.
If, in the 1st count, a below-line candidate wins, and there is a cycle
containing above and below line candidates, then that voter wants to promote
all his/her above-line candidates to equal 1st place, for the purpose of the
2nd count.
If, in the 2nd count the same thing happens (a below-line candidate wins and
there is a cycle containing above and below line candidates), then that
voter, for the purpose of the 3rd count, wants to leave his above-line
candidatres all in equal 1st place, and rank his below-line candidates in
the order listed
The count computer carries out these ranking-changes and repeated counts.
[end of ARLO definition]
ARLO is surely useful for many other rank methods. It seems to me that AERLO
&/or ATLO wasn't suitable for Kevin's method that complies with FBC, SFC &
SDSC, because those options cause the loss of FBC.
Power truncation:
If a voter power truncates candidates belowe a particular rank position,
then, the count scores each one of those candidates as if that voter had
ranked all the other candidates over him/her.
[end of power truncation defionition]
Mike Ossipoff
More information about the Election-Methods
mailing list