[EM] New policy: No personal criticisms in on-topic discussion
nkklrp at hotmail.com
Wed May 18 18:39:28 PDT 2005
It's been suggested to me that if there's someone to whom I can' t reply
politely, then I shouldn't reply to them at all. I'm going to take that
advice. I've quit replying to Paul, and I'm going to quit replying to James
Sure, that's partly because there's so much objection to personal criticism,
but I'm making that choice just as much because replying to people like that
isn't a productive use of my time.
That new politeness policy only applies to on-topic discussion, not to posts
of which I'm the topic. And my pledge to not reply to those llistmembers
applies only to on-topic posts. For instance, if I'm the topic, or if
politics is the topic, this non-reply pledge doesn't apply.
And of course if I made that declaration about not replying to certain
people after they'd posted messages that I haven't replied to yet, then it
could seem as if I was using that as an evasion to avoid replying to those
messages, as if those messages said something irrefutable. For that reason
I'm going to reply to one more message from each of those two.
My reply to James is a reply to a message from last month. My reply to Russ
is to a message from about half a week ago. It will be posted maybe in a few
days, or maybe in a few weeks.
That reply to James will be posted today.
FREE pop-up blocking with the new MSN Toolbar get it now!
More information about the Election-Methods