[EM] Condorcet baseball rankings
Paul Kislanko
kislanko at airmail.net
Fri Oct 29 14:31:16 PDT 2004
Before the expansion, MLB actually had a nearly perfect round-robin that
resulted in two teams meeting for the championship.
But in no case then or now was the result of a game determined by voting.
> -----Original Message-----
> From: election-methods-electorama.com-bounces at electorama.com
> [mailto:election-methods-electorama.com-bounces at electorama.com
> ] On Behalf Of Ted Stern
> Sent: Friday, October 29, 2004 4:11 PM
> To: election-methods at electorama.com
> Subject: [EM] Condorcet baseball rankings
>
> With all the games, baseball is nearly a perfect round robin
> tournament.
>
> I think a good criterion would be margins rather than winning
> games in this
> case, with winning games as the tie-breaker.
>
> Does this show that Boston and St. Louis would have won their
> league pennants?
>
> What if Condorcet for division winners? Any changes?
>
> ------------------------------
>
> http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/standings/grid
>
> MLB Standings Grid: 2004
> --------------------------------------------------------------
> -----------------
> MLB Standings
>
> American League Team-By-Team Standings Grid
>
> Tms vs. vs. vs. vs. vs. vs. vs. vs. vs. vs. vs.
> vs. vs. vs. Intr
> Ana Bal Bos CWS Cle Det KC Min NYY Oak Sea
> TB Tex Tor Lg
> Ana -- 6-3 4-5 5-4 4-5 7-2 7-0 5-4 5-4 10-9 13-7
> 6-1 9-10 4-5 7-11
> Bal 3-6 -- 10-9 2-4 3-3 6-0 6-3 4-5 5-14 0-7 7-2
> 11-8 5-2 11-8 5-13
> Bos 5-4 9-10 -- 4-2 3-4 6-1 4-2 2-4 11-8 8-1 5-4
> 14-5 4-5 14-5 9-9
> CWS 4-5 4-2 2-4 -- 10-9 8-11 13-6 9-10 3-4 2-7 7-2
> 4-2 6-3 3-4 8-10
> Cle 5-4 3-3 4-3 9-10 -- 9-10 11-8 7-12 2-4 6-3 5-4
> 3-3 1-8 5-2 10-8
> Det 2-7 0-6 1-6 11-8 10-9 -- 8-11 7-12 4-3 4-5 5-4
> 3-3 4-5 4-2 9-9
> KC 0-7 3-6 2-4 6-13 8-11 11-8 -- 7-12 1-5 2-7 2-5
> 3-6 4-5 3-3 6-12
> Min 4-5 5-4 4-2 10-9 12-7 12-7 12-7 -- 2-4 2-5 5-4
> 4-5 5-2 4-2 11-7
> NYY 4-5 14-5 8-11 4-3 4-2 3-4 5-1 4-2 -- 7-2 6-3
> 15-4 5-4 12-7 10-8
> Oak 9-10 7-0 1-8 7-2 3-6 5-4 7-2 5-2 2-7 -- 11-8
> 7-2 11-9 6-3 10-8
> Sea 7-13 2-7 4-5 2-7 4-5 4-5 5-2 4-5 3-6 8-11 --
> 2-5 7-12 2-7 9-9
> TB 1-6 8-11 5-14 2-4 3-3 3-3 6-3 5-4 4-15 2-7 5-2
> -- 2-7 9-9 15-3
> Tex 10-9 2-5 5-4 3-6 8-1 5-4 5-4 2-5 4-5 9-11 12-7
> 7-2 -- 7-2 10-8
> Tor 5-4 8-11 5-14 4-3 2-5 2-4 3-3 2-4 7-12 3-6 7-2
> 9-9 2-7 -- 8-10
>
> National League Team-By-Team Standings Grid
>
> Tms vs. vs. vs. vs. vs. vs. vs. vs. vs. vs.
> vs. vs. vs. vs. vs. vs. Intr
> Ari Atl ChC Cin Col Fla Hou LA Mil Mon
> NYM Phi Pit SD SF StL Lg
> Ari -- 2-4 4-2 3-3 6-13 3-4 2-4 3-16 3-3 0-6
> 3-4 1-5 2-4 7-12 5-14 1-5 6-12
> Atl 4-2 -- 3-3 2-4 4-2 14-5 3-3 4-3 4-2 15-4
> 12-7 10-9 4-2 3-3 4-3 2-4 8-10
> ChC 2-4 3-3 -- 9-8 5-1 3-3 10-9 2-4 10-7 3-3
> 4-2 3-3 13-5 4-2 2-4 8-11 8-4
> Cin 3-3 4-2 8-9 -- 3-3 4-2 6-11 4-2 10-8 4-2
> 3-3 3-3 9-10 2-4 3-3 5-14 5-7
> Col 13-6 2-4 1-5 3-3 -- 1-5 1-5 8-11 2-4 2-4
> 1-5 5-3 2-4 10-9 8-11 1-5 8-10
> Fla 4-3 5-14 3-3 2-4 5-1 -- 3-3 3-3 4-2 11-8
> 15-4 12-7 1-5 4-2 2-5 2-4 7-11
> Hou 4-2 3-3 9-10 11-6 5-1 3-3 -- 1-5 13-6 2-4
> 2-4 6-0 12-5 2-4 2-4 10-8 7-5
> LA 16-3 3-4 4-2 2-4 11-8 3-3 5-1 -- 3-3 4-3
> 3-3 1-5 6-0 10-9 10-9 2-4 10-8
> Mil 3-3 2-4 7-10 8-10 4-2 2-4 6-13 3-3 -- 5-1
> 2-4 0-6 6-12 2-4 1-5 8-9 8-4
> Mon 6-0 4-15 3-3 2-4 4-2 8-11 4-2 3-4 1-5 --
> 9-10 7-12 4-2 1-6 1-5 3-3 7-11
> NYM 4-3 7-12 2-4 3-3 5-1 4-15 4-2 3-3 4-2 10-9
> -- 8-11 1-5 1-6 4-2 1-5 10-8
> Phi 5-1 9-10 3-3 3-3 3-5 7-12 0-6 5-1 6-0 12-7
> 11-8 -- 3-3 5-1 2-4 3-3 9-9
> Pit 4-2 2-4 5-13 10-9 4-2 5-1 5-12 0-6 12-6 2-4
> 5-1 3-3 -- 3-3 5-1 5-12 2-10
> SD 12-7 3-3 2-4 4-2 9-10 2-4 4-2 9-10 4-2 6-1
> 6-1 1-5 3-3 -- 12-7 2-4 8-10
> SF 14-5 3-4 4-2 3-3 11-8 5-2 4-2 9-10 5-1 5-1
> 2-4 4-2 1-5 7-12 -- 3-3 11-7
> StL 5-1 4-2 11-8 14-5 5-1 4-2 8-10 4-2 9-8 3-3
> 5-1 3-3 12-5 4-2 3-3 -- 11-1
>
>
> --
> Send real replies to
> ted stern at u dot washington dot edu
>
> Frango ut patefaciam -- I break that I may reveal
>
> ----
> Election-methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em
> for list info
>
More information about the Election-Methods
mailing list