[EM] Survey Results

[Eric Gorr]

A few weeks ago I mentioned that I was going to run an Oscar Vote for 
a local movie group that I am involved in in the Washington DC area.

Had a total of 17 voters.
Everyone did not vote in each category.
I have include the complete ballots.
There were no ties, when votes were submitted, and only a single 
cycle was generated.

This poll has an interesting property that not all voters would have 
been familiar with each of the options, electing to rank only those 
options they were  familiar with...a property that would likely be 
shared with any real election with many candidates.

I enjoyed introducing Condorcet methods to nearly 800 people in the DC Area...

Anyone know of a web-based IRV voting calculator into which I can 
past these ballots? Did a brief google search and couldn't find 
anything. Would be interested in comparing results.

Anyone else have any interesting analysis to add?


ACTOR IN A LEADING ROLE
>  ACTOR IN A LEADING ROLE
>  A. Johnny Depp - PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN: THE CURSE OF THE BLACK PEARL
>  B. Ben Kingsley - HOUSE OF SAND AND FOG
>  C. Jude Law - COLD MOUNTAIN
>  D. Bill Murray - LOST IN TRANSLATION
>  E. Sean Penn - MYSTIC RIVER

1:B>E>D>C>A
1:E>D
1:B>D
1:E
1:D>E>B>C
1:A>D>C>E>B
1:E=D>A>B>C
1:D
1:A>D>C>B>E
1:B>E>D=A>C
1:D>E>A
1:D=E>A>B>C
1:B>E>C>A
1:E>A>D>C>B
1:D>E>A>C>B

Winner: D - Bill Murray - LOST IN TRANSLATION
No cycles.


ACTOR IN A SUPPORTING ROLE
>  A. Alec Baldwin - THE COOLER
>  B. Benicio Del Toro - 21 GRAMS
>  C. Djimon Hounsou - IN AMERICA
>  D. Tim Robbins - MYSTIC RIVER
>  E. Ken Watanabe - THE LAST SAMURAI

1:D>C>B
1:D>C
1:C
1:D
1:D>B>A>C
1:A=D>C=E>B
1:A>D>C>E>B
1:D>B>C>A>E
1:B=A>D>C>E
1:E
1:B>D>A>C>E
1:B>D>A>E>C
1:E>D
1:D>B
1:D>A>B>C>E

Winner: D - Tim Robbins - MYSTIC RIVER
No cycles


ACTRESS IN A LEADING ROLE
>  A. Keisha Castle-Hughes - WHALE RIDER
>  B. Diane Keaton - SOMETHING'S GOTTA GIVE
>  C. Samantha Morton - IN AMERICA
>  D. Charlize Theron - MONSTER
>  E. Naomi Watts - 21 GRAMS

1:A>D>C
1:D>B>C>A>E
1:D>A=C=E>B
1:D
1:D>A>C>E>B
1:D=E>A>C>B
1:D>E>C
1:A>D>E
1:E>D>C>B>A
1:D>E>A>C
1:D>A>B>E
1:D
1:D>B>A>C>E
1:D>A=C=E>B

Winner: D - Charlize Theron - MONSTER
No cycles


ACTRESS IN A SUPPORTING ROLE
>  A. Shohreh Aghdashloo - HOUSE OF SAND AND FOG
>  B. Patricia Clarkson - PIECES OF APRIL
>  C. Marcia Gay Harden - MYSTIC RIVER
>  D. Holly Hunter - THIRTEEN
>  E. Renee Zellweger - COLD MOUNTAIN

1:E>B
1:C>E
1:A
1:E
1:E=A>B>C
1:B>E>D>C>A
1:E>A>C=D>A
1:C
1:B>E=C>D>A
1:B>C>D
1:A
1:C>E>A>D>B

Winner: E - Renee Zellweger - COLD MOUNTAIN
There was a cycle here involving ABC...resolved by rejected the B>C defeat.


ANIMATED FEATURE FILM
>  A. BROTHER BEAR
>  B. FINDING NEMO
>  C. THE TRIPLETS OF BELLEVILLE

1:B>C>A
1:B
1:C
1:B>C>A
1:C>B
1:C
1:B>C>A
1:C>B
1:C>B
1:B
1:C
1:B>A>C
1:C>B>A

Winner: E - THE TRIPLETS OF BELLEVILLE
no cycles


ART DIRECTION
>  A. GIRL WITH A PEARL EARRING
>  B. THE LAST SAMURAI
>  C. THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
>  D. MASTER AND COMMANDER: THE FAR SIDE OF THE WORLD
>  E. SEABISCUIT

1:E>A
1:C>E
1:A
1:C>D>E
1:A>B>C
1:B
1:A>B>D>C>E
1:D>C>B>E
1:C>B>A
1:C
1:C>B>A>D>E
1:C>D>A>B>E

Winner: C - THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
no cycles


BEST PICTURE
>  A. THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
>  B. LOST IN TRANSLATION
>  C. MASTER AND COMMANDER: THE FAR SIDE OF THE WORLD
>  D. MYSTIC RIVER
>  E. SEABISCUIT

1:D>A>E>B>C
1:A>D>B>E>C
1:B>C=D=E>A
1:A
1:E>D>A
1:A>B>D>C>E
1:D>A>B
1:B>C>A>E
1:B
1:B>E>C>A>D
1:D>A>B>C>E
1:B>C>A>D>E
1:A>B>D>C>E
1:A>D>E>B>C
1:A>E>D>C>B


Winner: THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
no cycles


CINEMATOGRAPHY
>  A. CITY OF GOD
>  B. COLD MOUNTAIN
>  C. GIRL WITH A PEARL EARRING
>  D. MASTER AND COMMANDER: THE FAR SIDE OF THE WORLD
>  E. SEABISCUIT

1:B>E
1:B>A
1:E
1:D>B>E
1:A>B>D>E
1:B>D>A>C>E
1:A
1:C>A=D>B>E
1:A>D>E
1:B>D>C>A>E
1:A>C>B
1:A>C>B>D>E

Winner: A - CITY OF GOD
no cycles


COSTUME DESIGN
>  A. GIRL WITH A PEARL EARRING
>  B. THE LAST SAMURAI
>  C. THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
>  D. MASTER AND COMMANDER: THE FAR SIDE OF THE WORLD
>  E. SEABISCUIT

1:C>E
1:C>D>E
1:B
1:A>B=C
1:B>C>D>E
1:C>B
1:C
1:C

Winner: C - THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
no cycles


DIRECTING
>  A. CITY OF GOD
>  B. THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
>  C. LOST IN TRANSLATION
>  D. MASTER AND COMMANDER: THE FAR SIDE OF THE WORLD
>  E. MYSTIC RIVER

1:E>B>C
1:B>A>E>C>D
1:B
1:B>E>D>C
1:A>B>E>D>C
1:B>A>C>E>D
1:B>E>C
1:B>A>C=D
1:A
1:A>C>D>B>E
1:A>E>B>C>D
1:A>C>D>B>E
1:B=C>E
1:E
1:B>C>D>A>E
1:B>E>A

Winner: B. THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
no cycles


DOCUMENTARY FEATURE
>  A. BALSEROS
>  B. CAPTURING THE FRIEDMANS
>  C. THE FOG OF WAR
>  D. MY ARCHITECT
>  E. THE WEATHER UNDERGROUND

1:E
1:D
1:B
1:B>C>D
1:C>B>D>E>A
1:C>D>B
1:C=B
1:C
1:A

Winner: B. CAPTURING THE FRIEDMANS
no cycles


DOCUMENTARY SHORT SUBJECT
>  A. ASYLUM
>  B. CHERNOBYL HEART
>  C. FERRY TALES

(no votes recorded)
(winner selected by random ballot)

Winner: B. CHERNOBYL HEART
no cycles


FILM EDITING
>  A. CITY OF GOD
>  B. COLD MOUNTAIN
>  C. THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
>  D. MASTER AND COMMANDER: THE FAR SIDE OF THE WORLD
>  E. SEABISCUIT

1:B>C>E
1:A>C>B>E>D
1:C
1:C>B>E>D
1:A>C>B>E>D
1:A>E>D>C
1:A
1:D>A=E
1:A>D>C>E
1:C>E=B
1:A
1:C>A>B>E>D
1:C

Winner: A. CITY OF GOD
no cycles


FOREIGN LANGUAGE FILM
>  A. THE BARBARIAN INVASIONS
>  B. EVIL
>  C. THE TWILIGHT SAMURAI
>  D. TWIN SISTERS
>  E. ZELARY

1:A
1:A

Winner: A. THE BARBARIAN INVASIONS
no cycles


MAKEUP
>  A. THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
>  B. MASTER AND COMMANDER: THE FAR SIDE OF THE WORLD
>  C. PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN: THE CURSE OF THE BLACK PEARL

1:A>C>B
1:A
1:A>B
1:A>C>B
1:A>B>C
1:A>C>B
1:A
1:A>C>B
1:A>C>B

Winner: A. THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
no cycles


MUSIC (SCORE)
>  A. BIG FISH
>  B. COLD MOUNTAIN
>  C. FINDING NEMO
>  D. HOUSE OF SAND AND FOG
>  E. THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING

1:E>B>C>D>A
1:E>B
1:D>E
1:A
1:A>D>B>E
1:E>A>C>B>D
1:D>B=E>C>A
1:A>E>C
1:A>E
1:A
1:E
1:E

Winner: E. THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
no cycles


MUSIC (SONG)
>  A. "Into the West" - THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
>  B. "A Kiss at the End of the Rainbow" - A MIGHTY WIND
>  C. "Scarlet Tide" - COLD MOUNTAIN
>  D. "The Triplets of Belleville" - THE TRIPLETS OF BELLEVILLE
>  E. "You Will Be My Ain True Love" - COLD MOUNTAIN

1:A>E=C>D>B
1:A>E
1:E
1:C>D>B>A>E
1:B>E>C>D>A
1:D
1:D>E>C>A>B
1:D>A>B
1:A>B
1:B
1:A>D>B>C>E

Winner: D. "The Triplets of Belleville" - THE TRIPLETS OF BELLEVILLE
no cycles


SHORT FILM (ANIMATED)
>  A. BOUNDIN'
>  B. DESTINO
>  C. GONE NUTTY
>  D. HARVIE KRUMPET
>  E. NIBBLES

1:B
1:B
1:B
1:B

Winner: B. DESTINO
no cycles


SHORT FILM (LIVE ACTION)
>  A. DIE ROTE JACKE (The Red Jacket)
>  B. MOST (The Bridge)
>  C. SQUASH
>  D. (A) TORZIJA ([A] Torsion)
>  E. TWO SOLDIERS

(no votes recorded)
(winner selected by random ballot)

Winner: B. CHERNOBYL HEART
no cycles


SOUND
>  A. THE LAST SAMURAI
>  B. THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
>  C. MASTER AND COMMANDER: THE FAR SIDE OF THE WORLD
>  D. PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN: THE CURSE OF THE BLACK PEARL
>  E. SEABISCUIT

1:B>E>D
1:B
1:E
1:E>B=C
1:B>C=E
1:C>B>A>D>E
1:B>A>D>C>E
1:B>A
1:B

Winner: B. THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
no cycles


SOUND EDITING
>  A. FINDING NEMO
>  B. MASTER AND COMMANDER: THE FAR SIDE OF THE WORLD
>  C. PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN: THE CURSE OF THE BLACK PEARL

1:C>A>B
1:A
1:A
1:B>C>A
1:B>A>C
1:A
1:C>A>B

Winner: A. FINDING NEMO
no cycles


VISUAL EFFECTS
>  A. THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
>  B. MASTER AND COMMANDER: THE FAR SIDE OF THE WORLD
>  C. PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN: THE CURSE OF THE BLACK PEARL

1:A>C>B
1:A
1:A>B
1:A>C>B
1:A>C>B
1:A>B>C
1:A
1:A>B>C
1:A>C>B

Winner: A. THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
no cycles


WRITING (ADAPTED SCREENPLAY)
>  A. AMERICAN SPLENDOR
>  B. CITY OF GOD
>  C. THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING
>  D. MYSTIC RIVER
>  E. SEABISCUIT

1:D>C>A>E>B
1:A>B>C>D>E
1:A
1:A
1:B>A>E>C>D
1:A>B>C>D
1:D>C>A>B
1:A=B
1:B>A
1:D>A>B>C>E
1:B>A>C>E>D
1:A>D>E
1:A
1:C>D>A
1:C>E

Winner: A. AMERICAN SPLENDOR
no cycles


WRITING (ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY)
>  A. THE BARBARIAN INVASIONS
>  B. DIRTY PRETTY THINGS
>  C. FINDING NEMO
>  D. IN AMERICA
>  E. LOST IN TRANSLATION

1:D>C>E=B>A
1:D
1:B>D>E
1:D>B
1:E
1:E>B>C>D>A
1:E>D
1:D>B>E
1:B>E>D>C>A
1:B>A>E>C>D
1:E>C
1:D
1:E>B

Winner: E. LOST IN TRANSLATION
no cycles

The results were computed using my voting calculator & the ranked 
pairs option located at http://condorcet.ericgorr.net


-- 
== Eric Gorr ========= http://www.ericgorr.net ========= ICQ:9293199 ===
"Therefore the considerations of the intelligent always include both
benefit and harm." - Sun Tzu
== Insults, like violence, are the last refuge of the incompetent... ===