[EM] river, ROACC (terminolgy, again)

Paul Kislanko kislanko at airmail.net
Sat Aug 28 13:51:44 PDT 2004

I completely agree. Avoiding ambiguity was my only purpose in starting this
thread. "Randomized" more properly characterizes what was described as
"non-determinate", which has (several) precise definitions.

-----Original Message-----
From: Warren Schudy [mailto:wschudy at WPI.EDU] 
Sent: Saturday, August 28, 2004 3:13 PM
To: Paul Kislanko
Cc: election-methods-electorama.com at electorama.com
Subject: RE: [EM] river, ROACC (terminolgy, again)

On Sat, 28 Aug 2004, Paul Kislanko wrote:

> James Green-Armytage wrote in response to someone else:
> >Just to repeat myself [another time ;-] : We must consider
> >NON-DETERMINISTIC methods like ROACC (see my post on the
> >"recommendations" thread)
> "Non-Deterministic" is not a synonym for "method with a random component."
> In mathematical logic a "non-deterministic" method is one that solves a
> problem, but for which the complexity of the solution cannot be judged by
> the input to the problem.
> Thus a problem is "NP" if it can be solved in non-deterministic polynomial
> time, meaning in general it can't be known what the degree of the
> is just from looking at the input.

Your characterization of NP is incorrect. "Non-deterministic" in the
non-deterministic-polynomial (NP) complexity class refers to algorithms
that can be solved in polynomial time on a non-deterministic turing
machine. Please review your complexity theory. As usual, wikipedia has a
good discussion of these matters:


I'm not entirely sure what the phrase "non-deterministic" means. I've seen 
it used for two meanings:
-When computing something, avoiding making a decision by making all
possible decisions (back-tracking, non-deterministic turing machines)
-Using chance/randomness

To avoid this ambiguity, I suggest we use a different term for describing 
algorithms that use chance, such as "randomized".


| Warren Schudy                           |
| WPI Class of 2005                       |
| Physics and computer science major      |
| AIM: WJSchudy  email: wschudy at wpi.edu   |
| http://users.wpi.edu/~wschudy/          |

More information about the Election-Methods mailing list