[EM] simultaneous & secret
nkklrp at hotmail.com
Thu Jan 3 21:02:46 PST 2002
I think it would be best if
the criterion itself specifies that the ballots are simultaneous and
secret, at least in the English definition.
Maybe, but my concern would be that then someone could make a case for
that FBC doesn't apply to all voting systems. I like to say that, as far as
my criteria apply to all usable methods. Someone could argue that a
process makes a different voting system, one to which FBC no longer applies,
FBC only applies when ballots are simultaneous & secret.
Anyway, though that change may be right for an official version, it would
& complicate the public-debate version, since people would wonder why it's
to specify about ballots being simultaneous & secret. For effect, the fewer
better, in public debate.
Send and receive Hotmail on your mobile device: http://mobile.msn.com
More information about the Election-Methods