Eliminating the Wrong candidate
New Democracy
donald at mich.com
Sat Oct 17 08:53:39 PDT 1998
Dear Blake Cretney,
What I mean by the "Wrong Candidate" can be best shown by an example.
Suppose the following count of the first choices:
80A 60B 40C 22D
It is not acceptable to drop candidate C at the same time we drop
candidate D because the sum of the votes of C and D is greater than the
votes of candidate B.
We do not know how many of the 22 voters of candidate D would vote for
candidate C in a run-off election, but we must assume that it may be all of
them.
If so, this would give 62 votes to candidate C and move him ahead of B.
In this example candidate C would be a wrong candidate to be dropped.
The answer is to only drop one candidate before each of a series of
run-off elections until we have a majority winner. I think this is called
Exhaustive Ballots.
This may result in more than two elections.
Anyway, Choice Run-Off only drops one candidate at a time which makes
it superior to Top Two Run-Off.
Donald Davison
More information about the Election-Methods
mailing list