[EM] Canadian politician supports "a preferential ballot, or a ranked ballot"

Richard Fobes ElectionMethods at VoteFair.org
Thu Jan 17 09:07:39 PST 2013


Here is an interesting development in Canada.

Marc Garneau is running for the leadership of Canada’s national Liberal 
party, and his web page (at 
http://marcgarneau.ca/support-marc-democratic-reform/) says:

"If elected, my proposal would be to reform Canada’s electoral system by 
changing our voting process to a preferential ballot, or a ranked ballot.

Adrian, you now know enough to write a very short article for Democracy 
Chronicles about this increased interest for election-method reform. 
Wikipedia has info about him, including a photo of him when he was an 
astronaut.  I'm sure he would love the exposure.

This is happening somewhat near the top of a political party.  Currently 
he isn't the most likely winner for the leadership position, yet he is 
popular enough that he can attract significant attention to the issue of 
banning the use of single-mark ballots.

The counting method he recommends is instant-runoff voting (IRV), which 
is not the best choice.  Yet when used within a political party, this 
would be a big improvement, and the winner would never be from the 
"wrong" party.

Soon enough, just as has happened in Aspen (CO) and Burlington (VT), the 
weaknesses of IRV counting will get exposed.  In the meantime, just 
getting people to talk about, and think about, the possibility of better 
ballots and better counting methods is a wonderful development.

(The word "riding" in Canada is equivalent to "district" in the U.S.)

Richard Fobes





More information about the Election-Methods mailing list