[EM] Census re-districting instead of PR for allocating seats to districts.
juho4880 at yahoo.co.uk
Sun Jul 1 13:18:36 PDT 2012
I'd be happy to try that somewhere. Only those votes count that are cast.
This approach could be seen as less fair than the traditional population based allocation, since those people that didn't vote in some district will not be represented at all. In allocation between parties also non-voters will be represented (we may assume that their opinions will follow the opinions of those who voted). But as said, this is also a valid approach, and worth a try. We could as well think that those people who don't vote do not want to have a representative either.
On 1.7.2012, at 22.32, C.Benham wrote:
> I haven't been following this discussion closely, but I've long thought that the best way of allocating seats to multi-member districts is to just say that subject to every district having at least one seat we do the allocation after the votes have been cast, based on the numbers of people who actually vote.
> (Then within each district I favour STV-PR rather than any list system..)
> Competition between districts should help motivate an overall high turnout. But maybe there would be added incentives for skulduggery. :(
> Chris Benham
> Election-Methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info
More information about the Election-Methods