[EM] Condorcet How?
markus.schulze at alumni.tu-berlin.de
Mon Mar 22 03:17:13 PDT 2010
here are some interesting videos on IRV in Burlington:
I have the impression that there was no reasonable
debate on IRV. Most anti-IRV arguments were
ridiculous or simply false. The anti-IRV campaign
was a pure anti-Kiss campaign.
> in fact, if the election was decided with Condorcet
> rules (doesn't matter which, since there was no cycle),
> these same Republicans would have bitched all the more,
> since the Condorcet candidate had only 23% and came
> third in plurality. so the primary political motivation
> behind the repeal was not due to that the Condorcet
> winner was not elected.
I agree that the Republicans would also have attacked
Condorcet. But as Montroll was preferred to Wright with
56% against 44%, an anti-Condorcet/anti-Montroll campaign
wouldn't have been successful.
More information about the Election-Methods