[EM] Voting system "branding" poll

Jameson Quinn jameson.quinn at gmail.com
Sun Aug 29 14:04:10 PDT 2010


Oooh, very cool. Note that betterpolls.com allows you to see what other
people have used as write-ins, so that you don't duplicate ideas with slight
variations.

2010/8/29 Jameson Quinn <jameson.quinn at gmail.com>

> One thing I thought of too late to put it into the poll (I can't change it
> now, as there are already 4 votes) - we should also agree on an anti-brand
> for Plurality.
>
> Plurality
> First Past the Post (FPTP)
> One Vote Only
> The one-vote, lesser-evil (OVLE) system
> Favorite Hideous Space Reptile (FHSR) system<http://www.snpp.com/episodes/4F02.html>
> ....
>
> (Personally, I like OVLE. It's honest, without that slight hint of
> naming-bias which might taint the last suggestion. I honestly think that if
> we all started using "One Vote, Lesser Evil (OVLE)", it could catch on.)
>
> Do people think it's worth making another poll for this?
>
> JQ
>
> 2010/8/29 Jameson Quinn <jameson.quinn at gmail.com>
>
> IRV activists have done a good job "branding" their system. Although the
>> system was previously known as Hare voting, for its inventor, they chose a
>> short, descriptive name - IRV - and used it systematically to promote the
>> system. This is a crucial step for effective activism.
>>
>> I've created a poll for naming/branding four systems<http://betterpolls.com/do/1189>- Condorcet (Minimax); Bucklin (2+1 rank, equality-allowed); Range/Score;
>> and IRV (because, although the name "IRV" has been well-accepted, I've also
>> seen a recent proposal to call it "Greatest Majority Voting"). There's also
>> a for-interest-only option to choose your favorite systems overall. It's on
>> betterpolls.com, which can score winner via various systems. Write-ins
>> are allowed and the polling is open for the month of September; results are
>> closed until then to avoid path-dependent polling bias.
>>
>> Please vote in the poll and promote it (over email and/or social media).
>> Vote <http://betterpolls.com/do/1189>: you wouldn't want your preferred
>> system to come in last, would you?
>>
>> I personally commit to abide by any naming decisions of the poll (by
>> Range, known as "raw ratings summation" there on betterpolls), as long as
>> there are at least 25 votes and no clearly-superior write-ins (to be
>> confirmed, as necessary, in a later re-poll). I'd also help get relevant
>> URLs based on poll decisions.
>>
>> Jameson Quinn
>>
>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.electorama.com/pipermail/election-methods-electorama.com/attachments/20100829/2e7fbd4e/attachment-0004.htm>


More information about the Election-Methods mailing list