[EM] Using gerrymandering to achive PR
Raph Frank
raphfrk at gmail.com
Wed Sep 3 06:00:55 PDT 2008
1) Every odd year, an 'election' is held but voters vote for parties
2) based 1), seats are distributed using d'Hondt between the parties
3) Also based on 1), districts are modified so that they are
gerrymandered to give each party the correct number of seats
4) The following year, those districts are used for the House elections.
The results from 1) will give high accuracy info about the
distribution of support for the various parties (to the polling
station level). This should allow the districting in 3) to be very
effective.
Ofc, it depends on Congress not closing the 'loophole' that allows
districts to be modified more than once per decade.
I would also allow in 1) the voters to designate a backup party. If
the least popular remaining party has no seats, it is eliminated and
votes transferred to the voter's backup until all remaining parties
have seats (like PR-STV, but with no surplus distribution).
Also, if a party cannot be gerrymandered any seats, maybe it should be
eliminated, to allow its supporters votes to be useful.
Another question, would it be illegal to restrict candidates so that
they must come from the designated party? This would allow each party
to run 2 candidates in their district, thus improving choice.
More information about the Election-Methods
mailing list