[EM] Going down one rank position per Bucklin round
Paul Kislanko
kislanko at airmail.net
Fri Oct 21 17:21:08 PDT 2005
Mike Ossippoff wrote:
>
>
> Forest--
>
> You wrote:
>
> If you use a range style ballot, and just go down one slot
> per Bucklin move,
> then you could discard the majority defeated candidates. It
> might help
> mitigate the Clone Winner problem, too.
>
> I reply:
>
> But wouldn't that lose the method's FBC compliance? For FBC
> compliance, if
> there are N candidates ranked over a particular candidate, then it's
> necessary to give a vote to hat candidate in the (N+1)th
> round, and not
> before.
>
I think what Mike wrote is the same as what Forest wrote. It's hard to parse
Mike's statements, but "not before" the "(N+1)th" round is the same as
saying don't count it in the Nth round, where the winner was determined.
More information about the Election-Methods
mailing list