[EM] Rob: Condorcet's Criterion vs FBC. Will people favorite-bury?

[MIKE OSSIPOFF]

Rob--

You said that you don't think that significantly many people would 
favorite-bury in a public BeatpathWinner election.

A voter will favorite-bury if, for that voter, the important goal is to keep 
an unacceptable candidate from winning, and if favorite-burial will increase 
the probability of accomplishing that.

That's all the more lilkely when the voter doesn't know how BeatpathWinner's 
count works, and so doesn't know how likely it is that s/he'll regret not 
favorite-burying, and therefore won't want to take a chance.

But it doesn't depend on that. As as I said, I myself would favorie-bury in 
BeatpathWinner if it wouild decrease the probability that an unacceptable 
candidate would win.

And no, Rob, that isn't a stupid way of voting. It's the only way to vote if 
the important thing is to minimize the probabilitly that an unacceptable 
candidate will win.

For me, the problem with favorite-burial is when people don't agree on what 
is acceptable. Someone might favorite-bury by ranking over their favorite a 
candidate that some others consider unacceptable. For instance, many 
favorite-buriers in our current elections rank over their favorite someone 
whom I consider unacceptable.

FBC compliance gets rid of all favorite-burial incentive. Range Voting, 
Approval, and MDDA accomplishl that improvement.

If favorite-burial is happening because of FBC failure, then 
BeatpathWinner's compliance with Condorcet's Criterion, Smith's Criterion, 
and better criteria such as SFC & GSFC, won't give those favorite-burying 
voters any encouragement or reassurance. That's why FBC compliance is more 
important.

Because MDDA meets FBC and SFC, MDDA provides assurance to the voters who 
otherwise would need to favorite-bury, and also to the voters who don't need 
that assurance, and who, therefore, can benefit from the assurance that SFC 
compliance gives.

If it were up to me, public elections would use MDDA. Realistically, I 
propose RV, with more rating-levels than Approval.

Mike Ossipoff

_________________________________________________________________
Don’t just search. Find. Check out the new MSN Search! 
http://search.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200636ave/direct/01/