[EM] Arrow's Theorem flawed?
Abd ulRahman Lomax
abd at lomaxdesign.com
Fri May 13 08:57:03 PDT 2005
At 08:58 PM 5/12/2005, Curt Siffert wrote:
>I recently posted this addendum to the Arrow's Theorem page on
>wikipedia: It was immediately deleted for "bias". [...]
>Was I out in left field for writing this?
Have you asked in the comment page attached to the article? Another writer
here pointed out that an assertion was made about the alleged opinion of
some theorists without providing a reference. Without the reference, what
was said could indeed resemble biased writing, since appeal to undefined
authority is a characteristic of such writing. "Many experts say,..." is a
technique for asserting a bias without openly admitting it as a personal
opinion. Even if it is true. Rather, an encyclopedic way of writing might
be "According to So-And-So, professor of Hokum at the University of Serious
Delusion, the moon is indeed made of green cheese. Other experts who have
expressed similar opinions include Donald Duck, Micky Mouse, and the Jolly
Green Giant." :-)
(Of course, if the "experts" are asserted as such without a reasonable
basis, this would still be non-encyclopedic and likely to get deleted or
There might already be more specific discussion on the comment page, did
If inquiry about this on the comment page produces no satisfactory answer,
then reposting, writing in the wikipedia encyclopedic fashion, which would
include a specific reference when asserting a kind of authority that might
be controversial, might be appropriate. Anyone can delete changes, what
counts on wikipedia is what emerges as a consensus after discussion. I've
seen quite a few edits reversed and re-reversed....
So, consider the implicit criticism -- as you seem to be doing --, come to
your own conclusions, and respectfully assert it, if you think it will
improve the article. You have just as much right to your opinion as any
other wikipedian, except perhaps the owner, who mostly is an "absent god"
who allows mere mortals to work out their differences.
More information about the Election-Methods