[EM] math 103 website - Arrow & Saari
Markus Schulze
markus.schulze at alumni.tu-berlin.de
Wed Jan 9 08:38:59 PST 2002
Dear Forest,
you wrote (9 Jan 2002):
> How are "strategical nomination" problems and the clone
> problems related?
There are two kinds of strategical nominations: clones and
irrelevant alternatives.
An election method violates "Independence from Irrelevant
Alternatives" when there are situations where you can
increase the winning probability of a given already running
candidate by introducing an additional candidate.
An election method violates "Independence from Clones"
when there are situations where you can (1) increase or
decrease the probability that a candidate of a given set
of clones is elected by introducing additional clones to
this set of clones or (2) increase or decrease the
probability that a given candidate is elected by introducing
additional clones to a set of clones to which this candidate
doesn't belong.
"Independence from Irrelevant Alternatives" and "Independence
from Clones" describe two different nomination strategies.
Examples: Random Candidate meets "Independence from Irrelevant
Alternatives" and violates "Independence from Clones". Tideman's
Ranked Pairs method meets "Independence from Clones" and violates
"Independence from Irrelevant Alternatives".
Markus Schulze
More information about the Election-Methods
mailing list