[EM] Conditional YES votes
DEMOREP1 at aol.com
DEMOREP1 at aol.com
Sun Nov 25 15:31:16 PST 2001
If there are 3 or more choices, then obviously there may be a divided
majority.
Simple case-
YES votes
26 AB
24 BA
49 C
99
A later place YES vote might be deemed conditional -- i.e. so as NOT to
injure an earlier place YES vote that is not paired equally.
Example-
(* Yes conditional vote)
2 A B*
24 A B
24 B A
49 C
100
If C cannot win, then some of the C voters may vote a lesser of evils vote
for A or B.
(* Yes conditional vote)
2 A B*
24 A B
24 B A
46 C
3 C B
99
Without conditional YES votes-
A 50
B 51
C 49
A 100 percent clone should have the same YES or NO status as the original.
Example-
N1 ABC
N2 BCA
N3 CAB
N total
A 100 percent clone Z of A is added ---
N1 AZBC
N2 BCAZ
N3 CAZB
N total
If an A vote is YES or NO, then the each Z vote has the same YES or NO vote
status.
Of course, if a partial clone is added (some votes have Z ahead of A), then
some of the votes for it may be YES or NO.
As usual, I note that a YES vote may be barely above zero percent on a plus
100 percent to minus 100 percent scale.
As usual -- sorry -- but even a 49.99 percent of the votes choice with 100
percent support on each vote still loses.
The above is why simple Approval is defective -- i.e. it does not rank the
choices.
The above can also be used for coalition politics with divided majorities in
legislative bodies.
More information about the Election-Methods
mailing list