Minimizing need for insincerity

DEMOREP1 at aol.com DEMOREP1 at aol.com
Tue Sep 19 16:44:19 PDT 2000


Mr. Cretney wrote-

Clearly approval has more equal ranking problems then other methods,

but also has no order-reversal for first candidate.  These problems

have to be traded against each other.
--------
D- Approval has the mere problem of having equal rankings (especially near 
the majority level) ----

     True rankings
48 A
 2  ABC
48 B
 1  BC

99

A 50
B 51  wins
C 3

A has a first choice *true* majority but loses (due to the errors of the 2 
ABC voters).

A similar result might happen if 2 or more were being elected (such as 3 
judges with 10 candidates).

However, since the winners have the highest majorities it is a whole lot more 
democratic than the total evil of simple plurality.



More information about the Election-Methods mailing list