[EM] Salva Count

DEMOREP1 at aol.com DEMOREP1 at aol.com
Thu Apr 29 14:55:49 PDT 1999


Mr. Davidson wrote in part--
    48 ABC              36 BAC                24 CB
    12 ACB              12 BCA                12 CBA

Putting the votes in vertical form--
48 ABC              
36 BAC                
24 CB[A]
12 ACB              
12 BCA                
12 CBA

 Head to Head--
60 AB 84
96 AC 48
96 BC 48

C is beat by both A and C
B beats A

Mr. Davidson continues (as he has for about 2 plus years) to be unable to 
understand elementary Condorcet head to head math (thereby scrambling the 
thinking of new EM members).

However, he does a very good job of producing examples showing obvious 
defects of Borda type scale votes and its variations.



More information about the Election-Methods mailing list