Exaggerated opinions

DEMOREP1 DEMOREP1 at aol.com
Tue May 5 23:45:48 PDT 1998

Mr. Saari wrote:
In a rated vote (where a distinct "opinion" is expressed for every
possibility), it is possible to conduct the decision process with a method
where each alternative is proposed and voted on independently.  (Assume this
is done in parallel, meaning that a variety of proposals/alternatives can be
pending simultaneously.)  This means that new alternatives can be conceived
and proposed ad hoc by the members on an as-needed basis.  This method is non-
dictatorial because all new alternatives can appear whenever desired by any
given member (subject to any other existing rules regarding new proposals -
assume that such rules apply equally to all members).

In contrast, in a ranked vote ( where alternatives are ordered first, second,
third, etc.) it is necessary to compile a "final list of alternatives" before
any voting can occur.  The creation and presentation of the "final list" must
necessarily be performed by a subcommittee duly authorized to perform this
task.  I am unaware of any method involving ranked voting which does not also
necessarily involve the dictatorial pre-step of creating the "final list" (and
establishing an "official polling date/time").  Perhaps there is a method I am
not aware of?

D- With a world human population of around 5.5 billion, is Mr. Saari
suggesting that every indivdual have a proposal on any issue ? Is having a
minimal support requirement for any issue (i.e. some X percentage of the
membership) before it goes on the ballot (or agenda) being dictatorial ?  

The reality currently is that in all current public legislative bodies the
"leader" of the body or a small oligarchy of the body determines what will be
voted upon.   I repeat my suggested remedy - the highest percentage of all of
the members of the body who want a a vote on an issue should determine the
order of voting on issues (assuming the body is elected by the people using an
accurate proportional representation election method).

More information about the Election-Methods mailing list