[EM] Oops! Raynaud versions example: correction

Chris Benham chrisbenham at bigpond.com
Wed Dec 29 22:59:32 PST 2004


Chris Benham wrote  Wed.Dec.29:

>49: A
>24: B
>27: C>B
>
>A>C  49-27 (m 22)
>C>B  27-24  (m 3)
>B>A  51-49  (m 2)
>
>The three versions each give a different winner.  PO eliminates A and 
>elects C, failing Plurality.
>GL eliminates  B and elects C, failing  Minimal Defense.  Margins 
>eliminates C  and elects B.
>
One letter of this is wrong.  "GL"  (Raynaud(Gross Loser)) eliminates B 
and elects A (not C), failing Plurality.

I shall follow with posting the corrected version.

Chris Benham




More information about the Election-Methods mailing list